GRE : Analysis of an Argument-8





This essay on Analysis of an Argument-8 got
SIX out of SIX.

Read this Analysis of an Argument-8 carefully and note down the points for your future reference.




Example-8


Argument


The following appeared in the editorial section of a corporate newsletter.

The common notion that workers are generally apathetic about management issues is false, or at least outdated; a recently published survey indicates that 70 percent of the nearly 1,200 workers who responded to survey questionnaires expressed a high level of interest in the topics of corporate restructuring and redesign of benefits programs."

Question


Discuss how well reasoned you find this argument. In your discussion be sure to analyze the line of reasoning and the use of evidence in the argument. For example, you may need to consider what questionable assumptions underline the thinking and what alternative explanations or counter examples might weaken the conclusion. You can also discuss what sort of evidence would strengthen or refute the argument, what changes in the argument would make it more logically sound, and what, if anything, would help you better evaluate in conclusion.

Analysis


Based upon a survey among workers that indicates a high level of interest in the topics of corporate restructuring and redesign of benefits programs, the author concludes that workers are not apathetic about management issues. Specifically, he argues that since 79 percent of the 1200 workers who responded to the survey expressed interest in these topics, the notion that workers are apathetic about management issues is incorrect. The reasoning in this argument is problematic in several respects.

First, the statistics cited in the editorial may be misleading because the total number of workers employed by the corporation is not specified. For example, if the corporation employs 2000 workers, the fact that 79 percent of the nearly 1200 respondents showed interest in these topics provides strong support for the conclusion. On the other hand, if the corporation employs 200,000 workers, the conclusion is much weaker.

Another problem with the argument is that the respondents’ views are not necessarily representative of the views of the work force in general. For example, because the survey has to do with apathy, it makes sense that only less apathetic workers would respond to it, thereby distorting the overall picture of apathy among the work force. Without knowing how the survey was conducted, it is impossible to assess whether or not this is the case.

A third problem with the argument is that it makes a hasty generalization about the types of issues workers are interested in. It accords with common sense that workers would be interested in corporate restructuring and redesign of benefits programs, since these issues affect workers very directly. However, it is unfair to assume that workers would be similarly interested in other management issues - ones that do not affect them or affect them less directly.

In conclusion, this argument is not convincing as it stands.

To strengthen it, the author would have to show that the respondents account for a significant and representative portion of all workers. Additionally, the author must provide evidence of workers’ interest other management topics – not just those that affect workers directly.




This essay on Analysis of an Argument-8 got
SIX out of SIX.

Read this Analysis of an Argument-8 carefully and note down the points for your future reference.

The Analysis of an Argument-8 is quite different from the Analysis of an Issue.

Understand how the Analysis of an Argument-8 is different from the Analysis of an Issue and proceed.


Next Argument



Previous Argument



GRE-Model Questions Index



From Analysis of an Argument-8 to HOME PAG